Now, https-client accepts both:
https://ip.appspot.com/ (matching wildcard certificate)
https://github.com/ (matching non-wildcard certificate)
but still rejects
https://www.kegel.com/ (non-matching wildcard certificate)
which should match the behavior of these sites in a web browser.
The problem is that if you go to a website whose certificate does not
match its hostname, it should fail. Try this in a web browser for
https://www.kegel.com/ for example. Your web browser will say the
certificate is for *.pair.com, not for www.kegel.com, and won't let
you visit it without clicking through a bunch of scary warnings.
However, prior to this commit, https-client was happy to fetch
https://www.kegel.com/ without complaining. That is bad. Now, with
this commit, it will properly complain, which is good:
pelletier@chives:~/src/libevent/sample$ ./https-client https://www.kegel.com/
Got 'MatchNotFound' for hostname 'www.kegel.com' and certificate:
/C=US/postalCode=15203/ST=Pennsylvania/L=Pittsburgh/street=Suite 210/street=2403 Sidney Street/O=pair Networks, Inc./OU=Provided by pair Networks, Inc./OU=PairWildcardSSL $250,000/CN=*.pair.com
some request failed - no idea which one though!
error:14090086:SSL routines:SSL3_GET_SERVER_CERTIFICATE:certificate verify failed
ppelletier@chives:~/src/libevent/sample$
It will still succeed for sites with an exactly-matching certificate,
such as https://github.com/ and that is also good!
However, the problem is that the iSECPartners code doesn't handle
wildcards, which means we reject https://ip.appspot.com/ even though
it is perfectly legitimate, because we don't understand the wildcard:
ppelletier@chives:~/src/libevent/sample$ ./https-client https://ip.appspot.com/
Got 'MatchNotFound' for hostname 'ip.appspot.com' and certificate:
/C=US/ST=California/L=Mountain View/O=Google Inc/CN=*.appspot.com
some request failed - no idea which one though!
error:14090086:SSL routines:SSL3_GET_SERVER_CERTIFICATE:certificate verify failed
ppelletier@chives:~/src/libevent/sample$
So, we need to fix this. In other words, "to be continued..."
This made the difference between segfaulting and not segfaulting for
me when I run https-client, when I've built libevent using an OpenSSL
in a non-standard location.
In the same spirit as 1d9d5110a4aebf5833f6fd78bd0252affde0f4d0 and
d70af27d0152d0a87a25127faf215604beb8ffe0.
